Adventures in the Sociotechnical Umwelt: Absences of Quantum Computing Imaginaries in Speculative Fiction and Technology Governance
Abstract
This article stems from observing that, despite its surrounding hype, quantum computing has not been treated as the ‘novum’ of speculative fiction leading to quantum computing’s distinct absences within the cultural imaginary. Such absences are unique for technological governance, which is powerfully informed and directed by its surrounding cultural imaginaries, providing insight into the process of problem-finding in the governance endeavour.
We begin by separating out quantum computing from both quantum mechanics and other quantum technologies because the quantum signifier can muddy our analysis, especially since the latter are regular fixtures within the speculative fiction canon. I moderate my claim that quantum computing is absent in the speculative fiction canon by qualifying that its appearance usually serves as metaphorical portals into speculative worlds or as quasi-technological justifications to overcome significant technical and engineering hurdles in the narratives. To further reconcile this apparent contradiction between quantum computing’s often literal presence in speculative fiction and my claim of its absences, we spend some time with three of Istvan Csicsery-Ronay’s ‘Seven Beauties of Science Fiction’ to conclude that speculative fiction is not about quantum computing.
After setting out six observations from two absences I focus on problem-finding by way of affordances and adjacent-possibles that are illuminated through speculative fiction. As the absences of quantum computing imaginaries frustrate such endeavours, this lays the groundwork for the idea of sociotechnical umwelt which foregrounds the ‘controlled hallucination’ view of the human perceptual system. Here, the brain’s predictions are calibrated by incoming sensory signals in a continuous error minimisation process. The analogy that I seek to draw is obviously that the process of technology governance advances through similar principles: that our cultural imaginaries developed and disseminated through speculative fiction is projected into, and subsequently conflated with, the problem-portfolio of a given technology, directing our regulatory responses accordingly.
I then contextualise this idea of the sociotechnical umwelt within Jack Balkin’s ‘salience’ approach to technology governance and within the Collingridge Dilemma to indicate its immediate utility. Leveraging the centrality of perceptibility within technology governance, I deploy the sociotechnical umwelt as the outer limit of governability itself, and conclude with a plea for broadening the sociotechnical umwelt as a means of recognising latent harms.



