A Laboratory on the Road: Europe’s Regulatory Response to the Opacity of Autonomous Vehicles
Abstract
Established frameworks for vehicle regulation are not equipped to certify autonomous driving systems, given that their behaviour in real-world conditions cannot be fully inspected or verified in lab situations. This article examines how European regulators have responded to this challenge in Regulation 2022/1426, the first type approval framework for automated driving systems in Europe. The article extends Burrell’s three forms of algorithmic opacity to also capture the opacity of behaviours emerging from interactions in open, physical environments and uses this to analyse how the regulation responds to each form of opacity and how it distributes responsibilities between vehicle manufacturers, regulators and the public. The analysis identifies three regulatory transformations: operational design domains limit the scope of autonomous driving; scenario-based testing evaluates overall system behaviour rather than the mechanisms of specific components; and a shift towards on-road testing and after-market surveillance dissolves the boundary between testing and deployment. The result is a real-world experiment in which the public have been enrolled as subjects of a continuously extended laboratory. The article concludes that the current regulatory framework never resolves the uncertainties and risks within the type approval process, and instead opts for a continuous modulation of both regulation and technology after its market deployment.



